Why Was the Constitution a Controversial Document - 608 Words

Why was the Constitution a controversial document even as it was being written? The United States Constitution is the very foundation that the nation has been built upon, but its birth was not easy. The framers of the Constitution divided over many key issues relating to it and often argued at length over the creation, ratification, and implementation of this imperative document. Since the Constitution came into being it has been the epicenter of Civil Rights reforms, questions of state sovereignty versus national supremacy, and recently it has been looked to for questions about universal healthcare and what may or may not constitute a marriage. Currently the oldest â€Å"living† Constitution in the world; interpreting the United States†¦show more content†¦Finally, another controversial issue was that the Constitution itself did not specify what constituted citizenship, nor did it provide for specific rights to the citizenry of the United States; issues that spawned the Bill of Rights. Although a series of compromises were made to placate multiple interests the controversy surround the Constitution did not end with satisfied agreement by all parties. The Constitution was still hotly debated and opposed by some prolific leaders for the American Revolution, but due to a highly organized national propaganda campaign the Constitution was ratified in a relatively short amount of time. However, even with the Constitution ratified disputes over how it should be implemented trailed in its wake. A two party system emerged; though each side refused to admit that it was a two party system, and continued to contribute to a growing rift between advocates of a large/strong versus a small/weak federal government. The series of compromises made to ensure the success of the Constitution, while controversial, accomplished exactly that. The United States Constitution has survived through two World Wars, multiple natural disasters, economic depressions/recessions, and even the Civil War; and even that nearly tore the country in two. The Constitution will always be a controversial document because it retains a certain amount of adaptability forShow MoreRelatedThe Constitution as a Controversial Document Essay701 Words   |  3 Pagesï » ¿ Why Was The Constitution A Controversial Document Even As It Was Being Written? Name: Institution: Date of submission: Why Was The Constitution A Controversial Document Even As It Was Being Written? Introduction The United States Constitution was written more than 200 years ago and it has been used as the foundation for the government. The constitution has been and still remains the most durable political agreement in the history of the world. Even though an inspiringRead MoreThe Constitution Of The United States870 Words   |  4 PagesThe Constitution is a document that was created by the American people as a basic guide line for the country to follow. The Constitution is made up of twenty-seven amendments. These amendments are laws that everyone in the United States of America must follow. The Constitution is often viewed as a â€Å"living document†. The Constitution is thought of it in such a way because of its ability to be amended whenever it is needed to be amended. When the Constitution is amended, it will sometimes have documentsRead MoreCompromise of 18501069 Words   |  5 Pages At the time of the creation of the Constitution, the issue of slavery had been put off and av oided, a decision that would later lead to the controversy now known as the American Civil War. The composition, which was once the solution to problems that the Union was having, had the opposite effect in the 1850s, when arguments and different interpretations of the Constitution resulted in sectionalism, threat of secession, and tension between the North and the South. Abolitionists in the North triedRead MoreThomas Paine s Common Sense, Boston King s Memoir, And James Madison s Federalist Number 101584 Words   |  7 Pagesknew how important it was to hold on to significant documents we have access to read how our nation shifted into what it is today first hand. There are numerous documents available for anyone to study and become more acquainted with our past. Thomas Paine’s Common Sense, Boston King’s Memoir, and James Madison’s Federalist Number 10 are all important documents that helped shape America. In January 1776 Thomas Paine published the pamphlet, Common Sense. Paine’s Common Sense was written in order toRead MoreThe Necessary Evil That United The Colonies. Slavery Is1508 Words   |  7 Pageshistory, using White, Native American, and black African American slaves, it helped build this country in its beginning. Ultimately it was one of the worst atrocities in history. The inhumanity of it is still affecting the country today. So why did it take so long to abolish it when a majority of the Founding Fathers, while having slaves themselves, where apposed to it? Why did they not use their power to make a stand when they fought for this countries freedom in the revolutionary war? The Founding FathersRead MoreThe Debate On Constitutional Interpretation1730 Words   |  7 PagesThe debate on Constitutional interpretation is far from a new one. For years, the argument over how the Constitution should be read has varied, from the strict textualist approach to the most leni ent, the instrumentalist position. The Constitution has long been referred to in terms of being a living or dead document, and its interpretation has significant ramifications on this country’s legal climate. This paper will analyze and compare two different forms of Constitutional interpretation: originalismRead MoreThe Separation Of Church And State During The Colonies1312 Words   |  6 PagesExplain how the Great Awakening contributed to the development of the separation of church and state in the colonies. During the 18th and 19th century, or to be more precise, The Great Awakening was a response to the Enlightenment. Against the Enlightenment that is. That being so, it ended up being a major cause of the revolution in the long run. Not only that but the new religious messages that were emerging were increasingly more democratic overall becoming, in the U.S, messages of greater qualityRead MoreHow Democratic Is The American Constitution?1310 Words   |  6 Pages In which we are inbounded by our constitution that has been in effect for two centuries. In the book How Democratic is the American Constitution?, Robert A. Dahl questions the very idea that America is land of the free. He answers his question throughout the book with profound research and intriguing thoughts about how our constitution is outdated. Dahl’s piece did an exceptional job at fulfilling his purpose and makes the author really consider does document right for the Americans today or shouldRead MoreThe Debate Over The Method Of Constitutional Interpretation1556 Words   |  7 Pagescontenders of a loose interpretation argue that our understanding of the Constitution adapt with our society today and new developments that have been formed since it was first written. Conversely, strict constructionists argue that the interpretation of the Constitution must be based off of what is plainly written in the Constitution- nothing more and nothing less. The purpose of the Founding Fathers in 1787 was to construct a document that they believed would help pave the w ay for the American governmentRead MoreThe Case Of The United States Constitution1354 Words   |  6 Pages When relating a historical document to a contemporary situation, context is integral to proper analyzation. In the case of the United States Constitution, many political theorists share their opinion, on what they believe to be, the optimal interpretation of the document, however, only Antonin Scalia’s originalist ideology repels personal and moral views during analysis and encourages understanding the Constitution as originally intended. It is not the job of a United States judge, nor should it